Your Google Business Profile is probably the single most important free marketing tool you have, and small mistakes on it are costing you customers. We know because we look at these profiles every week for business owners across the Chattahoochee Valley.
When our team recently reviewed 450 Google Business Profiles across the Columbus, GA, Opelika, AL, and Auburn, AL, the average score came out to just 59.7 out of 100. Home service businesses and professional service firms scored the lowest of all.
Your Google Business Profile still decides who shows up on the map when someone searches near you. Now AI tools like ChatGPT and Gemini read that same profile to decide who to recommend. A messy or incomplete profile doesn’t just hurt you on Google. It hurts you everywhere someone might search for a business like yours.
Below are questions we hear most from business owners in Columbus, Phenix City, and Auburn.
What Is a Google Business Profile, and Is It Really Free?
A Google Business Profile is the free listing that shows up when someone searches for your business on Google or Google Maps. It shows your hours, your phone number, your reviews, and a pin on the map. Claiming it and keeping it updated costs nothing.
That’s exactly why we tell every business owner to start here before spending a dollar on ads. Knowing what a Google Business Profile actually includes, an active social presence, and a website that actually loads fast are the three free foundations worth getting right first. Paid ads work much better once those three are solid.
Do Reviews Actually Help My Google Business Profile Rank Higher?
Reviews help, but they’re not the whole story. Once your profile is filled out completely, in every category and every field, good reviews become table stakes. They keep you in the running. They don’t automatically move you past a competitor whose profile is just as complete.
The real tiebreaker is authority outside your profile: local press mentions, links from real websites, and a business people already recognize before they ever search. That kind of trust takes time to build. It won’t happen from reviews alone, no matter how many five-star ratings you collect. Google’s own guidance on local ranking backs this up: relevance, distance, and prominence all carry weight, and reviews are only one piece of prominence.
How Many Reviews Do I Need, and Does It Matter How Old They Are?
There’s no magic number to hit. What matters more is how recently you earned your last one. A profile with thirty reviews from three years ago tells Google, and any AI model reading it, that the business might not be very active anymore.
Customers feel the same way. A recent consumer review survey found that 74% of people look for reviews written in the last three months before they trust a business. Aim for a steady drip of new reviews, even just a couple a week, rather than a big pile from years back.
What Are the Most Common Mistakes We See on Google Business Profiles?
The same handful of mistakes show up again and again, no matter the industry. Businesses pick the wrong category. They skip listing their full service area. They never add their actual services. They stop posting updates. They upload only a few photos, or none at all.
None of these are hard to fix. They’re just easy to overlook. Working through a proper optimization pass on each of these is genuinely low-hanging fruit, and it’s often the fastest way to see a real jump in visibility within a few weeks.
Should I Have More Than One Google Business Profile If I Serve a Big Area?
Google ranks your profile largely on how close you are to the person searching. If you genuinely serve several cities that are hours apart, a second profile tied to a real, verifiable location can make sense.
What doesn’t work is creating extra listings with no real footprint behind them. Google has gotten stricter about verifying these, especially for home-based and mobile service businesses. If you serve a wide area from one location, expanding your service area settings inside your existing profile is usually the better move, paired with location pages on your website.
Do Yelp Reviews Matter If I’m Only Focused on Google?
Yes, more than they used to. In July 2026, OpenAI and Yelp announced a partnership that lets ChatGPT pull directly from Yelp reviews, ratings, and photos when it answers local search questions.
That means your Google Business Profile is no longer the only listing AI tools are reading. If your information is wrong or thin on Yelp, Apple Maps, or Facebook, it can drag down how confidently an AI model recommends you, even when your Google profile looks great. Keeping your name, address, and phone number exactly the same across every listing matters more now, not less.
Can I Use ChatGPT to Check My Own Google Business Profile?
Yes, and we recommend it. Open ChatGPT or Gemini and ask it to recommend a business like yours in your city. See if you show up. Then ask which sources it used to answer.
Click through to those sources and make sure your business information is correct and complete everywhere the AI model looked. This one habit catches problems most business owners never notice until a customer mentions it first.
You don’t have to sort through all of this alone. We’re not just a vendor, we’re your partner, and technology should serve you, not confuse you. Our team has spent nearly 30 years as a digital marketing agency in Columbus, Phenix City, and LaGrange, helping businesses get found by the people already searching for them. Schedule a call and get clarity on exactly where your Google Business Profile stands today.