“AI is changing SEO” has become one of those headlines that shows up everywhere and explains almost nothing. It’s vague enough to be scary and specific enough to make you think you’re already behind.
Here’s the good news, at least for local businesses in Columbus, Phenix City, and LaGrange: local search has actually been more resistant to AI’s takeover than almost any other kind of search. That’s not an accident, and it’s not going to last forever either. Let’s break down what’s actually happening and what you can do about it today.

Local Search Is Different From the Rest of Google
Google’s AI Overviews (the AI-written summaries now appearing at the top of many search results) have grown fast. They now reach over 2 billion monthly users, and roughly half of all U.S. search queries generate one.
But for local-intent searches, the kind where someone is looking for a business near them, AI Overviews still only appear in about 7% of queries. That’s a small fraction compared to other search types. Local search has stayed more traditional, at least for now, which means the businesses that show up well in traditional local search are still winning.
That said, the ground is shifting. Citation overlap between AI-generated answers and the traditional top-10 search results has dropped from around 76% in mid-2025 down to somewhere between 17% and 54% in early 2026. In plain terms: ranking #1 on Google no longer guarantees you’ll be the business the AI actually recommends.
ChatGPT Is Already Recommending Local Businesses
Here’s a stat worth sitting with: ChatGPT has become the third most common source of local business recommendations, right behind Google and Facebook.
That means when someone asks ChatGPT “what’s a good HVAC company near me” or “who does web design in Columbus GA,” it’s already answering with real business names. Whether your business is one of them depends on a few specific, controllable things.
What Actually Controls Whether AI Recommends You
Researchers have identified three factors that matter most for showing up in AI-generated local recommendations:
- Data accuracy across listings. Your business name, address, and phone number need to match exactly across your website, Google Business Profile, Yelp, Facebook, and anywhere else you’re listed.
- Review volume and response rate. Not just star rating, how many reviews you have and how consistently you respond to them.
- Cross-platform consistency. The AI is cross-referencing multiple sources. Inconsistent information anywhere creates doubt everywhere.
Star ratings matter too, and interestingly, different AI systems lean slightly different ways: ChatGPT tends to recommend businesses averaging 4.3 stars, compared to 3.9 on Gemini and 4.1 on Perplexity. The takeaway isn’t to chase a specific number, it’s that reputation management now has a measurable payoff beyond just looking good to a human reader.
What This Means If You’re Already Losing Clicks
If your website traffic has dipped even though your ranking hasn’t changed, the AI Overview presence on your search terms is a likely reason. Some of the most rigorous studies found organic click-through rates falling as much as 46.7% when an AI Overview appears above the results. The good news: that decline has been recovering as the ecosystem adjusts, up 85% from its low point by early 2026.
The honest takeaway here is that this is a real shift, not a passing scare. Ranking well still matters, but it’s no longer the whole story.
What To Actually Do About It
You don’t need to master AI or hire a data team. Focus on the fundamentals that are within your control:
- Audit your Google Business Profile. Make sure hours, categories, services, and contact information are complete and accurate.
- Check your listings for consistency. Your name, address, and phone number should match exactly across every platform you’re listed on.
- Build your review volume and response habit. Respond to every review, good or bad, within a few days.
- Keep publishing content that answers real customer questions. This is exactly the kind of content AI systems pull from when building an answer.
This is the same foundation strong local SEO has always been built on. AI hasn’t replaced it, it’s just raised the stakes for getting it right.
We’ve Watched This Kind of Shift Before
After nearly 30 years helping Columbus businesses navigate changes in search, this isn’t the first time the rules have moved. One of our longtime clients, the Kim Mixon Real Estate Team, is already appearing in AI-generated search results, not because they did anything special for AI specifically, but because they stayed consistent with local SEO for years. That consistency is exactly what’s paying off now.
If you’re not sure where your business stands in AI-driven local search, that’s worth finding out. Read more about what Google’s AI Overviews mean for your local business, or see how to turn Google Search Console into your ranking machine.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is local SEO less affected by AI than other types of search?
Yes, for now. AI Overviews currently appear in only about 7% of local-intent searches, much less than other search types. That could change, but today local search still rewards the traditional fundamentals.
Does ranking #1 on Google still matter?
It still matters, but it’s no longer a guarantee of AI visibility. Citation overlap between AI answers and the traditional top 10 has dropped significantly, meaning other factors like review consistency now carry real weight too.
Can I really get recommended by ChatGPT as a local business?
Yes. ChatGPT is already the third most common source of local business recommendations. Accuracy across your listings and a strong review response habit both influence whether that happens.
Do I need a certain star rating to show up in AI recommendations?
There’s no hard cutoff, but AI systems do tend to favor businesses with strong, consistent ratings and review volume. Focus on genuinely earning good reviews and responding to all of them rather than chasing a specific number.
What’s the single most useful thing I can do this month?
Audit your Google Business Profile and your review response habits. These are the most controllable, highest-impact factors identified in current research.
Is this a passing trend or a permanent shift?
It looks permanent. AI Overviews and AI-based recommendations are expanding, not shrinking. The businesses that adapt now by strengthening their fundamentals will be in the best position as it grows.
Alan Smith is the CEO of Tracsoft Enterprise and a digital marketing strategist with 25+ years of experience helping small businesses and nonprofits grow online. He is based in Columbus, Georgia.